Skip to main content

The Legend of Andrew Martin and the Third Law

  When it comes to robotics and science Isaac Asimov's creativity has fascinated me since I was a child. The particular reason I decided to title this review 'the legend of Andrew Martin' instead of the review of the Positronic Man or the 'Bicentennial Man' is simple. If you are a fan of Isaac Asimov's works you would know that he has a tendency to work on his characters to build his short stories and novelettes into novels. There's a movie that was also based on both works, that is titled the Bicentennial Man, and Andrew was played by Robin Williams in this movie. 

The story is based on a Robot who wanted to be declared legally a Human. The Pinnochio complex. The full summary can be found here: 

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Positronic_Man#Plot_summary 

 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Bicentennial_Man#Plot


The notion of a robot or an Android wanting to become human is not a new one, we see this in many books and in movies, and of course science fiction TV shows. For example, we have Lt. Commander Data from Star Trek of the Next Generation who pursues This course of thinking during the entire series. In fact, in some episodes, there were even legal challenges to Data rights even though he is an Android. Right out of the legend of Andrew Martin. You have the 1979 series Buck Rogers of the 25 century, where AI computers had the same legal rights as humans. I am sure there are others, Blade Runner (an adoption from Philip K. Dick's novel) among them. 

All interesting due to Andrew Martin. In fact, the science of robotics went in reverse. The 3 laws were made more powerful. With the emphasis on the second law, this kills the "robots' rights" clause, which only Andrew can make available to himself.  Now then here is a question and I haven't found a good answer to it. 

Could we say that Andrew Martin violated the 3rd law when he asked the robot surgeon to make adjustments that would end in Andrew's deactivation (death)??




Comments

Popular posts from this blog

"Movie Review: Dune Part 1 & 2 🎬

  Spoiler Alert! Buckle up for a desert journey like no other! In the vast expanse of cinematic adaptations, Villeneuve's Dune emerges as a monumental undertaking, spanning two epic installments that delve into the rich tapestry of Frank Herbert's iconic sci-fi saga. While paying homage to the source material, these films chart their own course, offering a visually stunning and thematically resonant exploration of power, prophecy, and the human condition. Part 1: Betrayal and Escape The journey begins with Duke Leto Atreides, a nobleman entrusted with the stewardship of Arrakis, a desert planet coveted for its reserves of the spice melange—a substance essential for space travel and coveted by factions across the universe. Accompanied by his son, Paul, and Lady Jessica, a member of the secretive Bene Gesserit sisterhood, Duke Leto embarks on a perilous mission to Arrakis. However, their arrival triggers a chain of events orchestrated by the insidious House Harkonnen and the shad

I had my Math test today...Epilepsy had other plans.

Today, I had my algebraic concept final test and I failed. Of course, my body sabotaged my efforts. This seems to be the norm with everything I do. That is when "everything I do" is extremely important and "the everything I do" maybe a life changer. Passing a math course is a life changer. So let me describe how it went today. Keep this note in mind I studied the entire weekend and the more I study things got more complicated As I wrote many times before, my neurologist and gastroenterologist have repeatedly told me that when my brain acts up my gut will too. When I take any other academic tests I usually don't get sick. I have taken all my meds and then I take life day by day. As I mentioned in previous posts on the internet maybe Facebook or G Plus, I have a few abnormalities in the brain. These abnormalities affect my behavior and my thought processes. It is not that bad but I perceive and understand things a little bit differently and that is why I may

Asimov's Foundation and Philosophy

  The essays in Asimov's Foundation and Philosophy are engaging and thought-provoking, and they offer new insights into one of the most influential science fiction series of all time. Here are some of the key philosophical themes that emerge from the essays: The ethics of manipulation: One of the central questions raised by the Foundation series is whether it is ethical to manipulate large populations of people in order to bring about a desired future result. Hari Seldon, the fictional founder of the Foundation, uses psychohistory, a science that can predict the future of large populations, to plan for the collapse of the Galactic Empire and the subsequent Dark Age. He does this in order to ensure that human civilization survives and eventually rebuilds. However, some people argue that Seldon's manipulation of the future is unethical, even if it is for a good cause. Free will vs. determinism: The Foundation series also raises the question of whether humans have free will or whe