Skip to main content

Section 31 To Die Standing

Die Standing (Star Trek: Discovery, #7)Die Standing by John Jackson Miller
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

While the novel's premise sets up an escalating, high-stakes interstellar mystery, it ultimately struggles with the execution of its central figure. The narrative kicks into high gear when Emony Dax—a clever, unjoined Trill nod to Deep Space Nine lore—uncovers a wandering space cloud that decimates a Federation starship.

The plot thickens when Philippa Georgiou recognizes the anomaly as a biological superweapon she failed to capture back in the Mirror Universe. Sent by a deeply distrustful Section 31 to investigate the isolationist Troika territory, Georgiou is saddled with a crew of "handlers" made up of deep-cut Star Trek lore characters.

On paper, the book attempts to balance Georgiou’s ruthless, imperial nature with the grit needed to survive a lethal alien frontier—demonstrating exactly why Section 31 finds her valuable, yet impossible to control.

The Critique: A Regression in Character Development

The Verdict: The novel’s portrayal of the former Emperor fundamentally clashes with her established arc in Star Trek: Discovery Seasons 1 and 2.

Instead of the complex, layered anti-hero we see evolving on screen, the book flattens her into a standard-issue sociopath. While the show highlighted a twisted but genuine capacity for affection (particularly regarding her bond with Michael Burnham) and a Pragmatic sense of survival, the novel strips away that nuance. By leaning too hard into pure, unadulterated sociopathy, the narrative misses the delicate balance that made Michelle Yeoh’s live-action portrayal so compelling. It's a fun ride for the lore drops, but a disservice to Georgiou's actual growth.

View all my reviews

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Siege of Eternity by Frederik Pohl My rating: 2 of 5 stars This book continues the Eschaton series, yeah you going to see that in the header. There really isn't much to say in this second book. All we know that two civilization is at war and the earth is just one of many civilizations where it has been targeted for assimilation to the "Beloved Leaders" empire. the interesting part is thru out the series is the Eschaton. I decided to look it up. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/End_time At least 2 advanced races/species are fighting to see who will rule... eternity. Frederick Pohl apparently believed in the Big Crunch theory and expressed his concept in this series the advanced species have given religion to the subjected races or species the other side's beliefs are not so credible. Their religion is very similar to Human beliefs of an afterlife which are present in the majority of cultures on our planet. In the end, the winning species and their allies or subject...
Post a Comment
Read more

Echo of worlds

Echo of Worlds by M.R. Carey My rating: 2 of 5 stars M.R. Carey's "Echo of Worlds" serves as a powerful and satisfying conclusion to his "Pandominion" duology, following the intriguing setup of "Infinity Gate." While the author's broader works certainly explore diverse realms, this novel masterfully ties together the threads of this particular multiversal conflict. The story immediately plunges readers into an epic war across countless dimensions. On one side stands the organic Pandominion, pitted against the chilling machine-intelligence known as the Ansurrection. Both factions are escalating their destructive capabilities, threatening to unleash an extinction-level event called the "Scour," which could wipe out thousands of planets. At the heart of this desperate struggle is the artificial intelligence, Rupshe. Convinced that the "Scour" is inevitable without intervention, Rupshe assembles a captivating and unlikely team fr...
Post a Comment
Read more

📝 Review Summary: Children of Memory

Children of Memory by Adrian Tchaikovsky My rating: 4 of 5 stars Children of Memory (Children of Time Series #3) is an essential, challenging, and mind-bending addition that shifts the series' focus from galactic evolution to a profound crisis of identity and reality. Note: This cannot be read as a standalone novel and contains major spoilers. Core Plot & Major Twist The novel revolves around a struggling human colony on the world of Imir. The central puzzle is the repeated ship crashes. The Engine: The crashes are revealed to be "intentional" because an ancient, alien Simulation Engine beneath Imir copies the consciousness of approaching life and inserts the duplicates into a simulated, rapidly aging environment. The Reveal: The original human colonists and the Skipper crew's landing party (including the Interlocutor, Miranda) were all physically destroyed. The "people" living on Imir—including the simulated Miranda and the copies of Portiid (Fabian)...
Post a Comment
Read more